4. 2008 Ford Taurus: $2,670
The full-sized Ford Taurus isn’t a flashy car. It doesn’t have a go-fast attitude, or a sexy design. It’s a perfectly hum-drum vehicle, which is what makes it a cheap vehicle to insure for teenagers. Add in the fact that it gets perfect scores across the board by NHTSA, and you’ve got one of the safest vehicles out there.