2. 2013 Toyota Tacoma
The Tacoma’s placement on this list should come as no surprise to anyone following the compact pickup storyline. With so few compact pickups on the market, the Tacoma is sitting on-top in terms of value and capability. Available under $20,000 the Tacoma is a popular vehicle for those looking for a work-friendly truck as well as typical Toyota reliability. After 36 months, the Toyota Tacoma is still worth 70.3 percent and 57 percent after 60 months.