4. Lexus CT200h (42 mpg)
The last Lexus on the list is the diminutive CT200h. By combining a 1.8L engine with an electric motor, the CT200h manages to put out 134 hp. For just $32,050 this Lexus achieves 42 mpg combined, and although it’s far from quick it’s still has a sporty feel due to its small size and short wheelbase.