2. BMW 3 Series: 471 Thefts
The popular BMW 3 Series model was even well-loved with the thieves. There were 471 thefts reported from 2009-2012. The 3 Series actually received its refresh in the 2012 model year but has added more powerplant options since including the 328d diesel that gets 45 mpg on the highway. As for the base model 3 Series, the 320i, it is priced from $33,475 and comes with 180 hp and gets a 36 mpg highway rating. Also available is the powerful 335i with 300 hp and a starting price of $44,125.