2014 Lexus IS 350 F Sport vs 2013 Cadillac ATS 2.0T

Can either newcomer put a scare into the BMW 3 Series?

2014 Lexus IS 350 F Sport vs 2013 Cadillac ATS 2.0T

For as long as we (and probably most of you) can remember, there’s really only been one benchmark in the compact luxury sport sedan segment: the BMW 3 Series. Sure, there have been a few contenders and more than a few pretenders, but the 3 Series has consistently outperformed the competition by offering a driving experience that’s engaging enough to feel like foregoing sports car ownership hasn’t diminished your manhood.

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 13Lexus has been trying to take a bite out of the 3 Series for almost a quarter of a century now, but truth be told, the luxury division of Toyota hasn’t had much success challenging BMW in terms of driving excitement. Things are changing at Toyota, though, the Lexus LFA boldly proclaiming the brand’s renewed interest in world-class performance. And the new 2014 Lexus IS certainly appears to be a serious effort, its Chief Engineer having publicly stated that the target was to be the most fun-to-drive car in the segment.

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 06Meanwhile, Cadillac has been going through something of a renaissance of its own, slowly shedding its old man image thanks to the V-spec variants of its CTS sedan, coupe and wagon. And with the ATS claiming the 2013 North American Car of the Year award along with surprising proclamations by the media (including an early review by our very own Colum Wood) that it out-handles the BMW 3 Series, it was inevitable that we’d pit the ATS against the new Lexus IS at our local test track.

WHERE’S THE BIMMER?

Get the Flash Player to see this player.

Yes, we would have liked to bring a BMW 3 Series along to set a baseline to measure the ATS and IS against, but BMW didn’t have one available (that they’d let us put on the race track). So instead, we’ll have to make the best of the situation by briefly comparing the numbers on our 2.0-liter Turbo Performance AWD Caddy and our IS 350 F Sport Lexus. Admittedly two disparate trim levels, compare their prices and it’s not such a stretch.

While a 2.0-liter turbo model can be purchased for just a little over $36,000, add on AWD and upgrade to the Performance trim level and you’ll have added $10,000 to that price.

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 10The IS 350 comes in at a more significant $39,465 to start, though all the F-Sport goodies don’t cost an absolute fortune and will set you back an additional $3,620 for an as-tested price of $43,980 including delivery. That F Sport package includes 18-inch wheels wrapped in high performance summer tires, twin projector LED headlights, and of course that aggressive front fascia and grille.

Trim out a BMW 328i with the Sport Line package and a few other add-ons like driver assistance and lighting packages and you’re quickly up into the same ballpark at $49,375.

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 08Of the three, the Bimmer has the worst power-to-weight ratio, a function of having the least powerful engine, a 2.0-liter turbocharged 4-banger that puts out 240 hp, while not exactly being a lightweight at 3,410 lbs. The IS 350 is the horsepower leader here, it’s widely used 3.5-liter V6 making a solid 306 hp, but it’s also the heaviest at 3,593 lbs. The all-wheel drive ATS sits in the middle on both counts, thanks to its 272 hp turbocharged 2.0-liter engine and a curb weight of 3,537 lbs, though in rear-wheel drive trim it’s actually 52 lbs lighter than the BMW. 

WHERE’S THE JOY?

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 16

There’s a lot more to performance and driver enjoyment than just power-to-weight ratio, though, a truth Toyota has recently taken to a whole new level with the incredibly agile GT-86 (Scion FR-S and Subaru BRZ in our market). But has any of the purity of the GT-86 experiment trickled uphill to Toyota’s luxury division and into the DNA of the new IS?

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 22Visually, there’s certainly a lot of joy in the F Sport front fascia, its gapping maw and unique LED “swooshes” beneath the main headlamps giving it a bold and exuberant appearance. The optional and totally awesome digital instrumentation, inspired by the LFA’s similarly high-tech gauge cluster, also suggests you’ve just buckled yourself into a serious performance machine, but out on the race track the experience is considerably more subdued.

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 20For starters, there’s no manual gearbox option in this or any other Lexus, so there’s an immediate disconnect between man and machine. Not that all automatic transmissions are incapable of delivering immediate on-demand gear changes, but in the IS 350 I was often having to request downshifts multiple times before the transmission would comply, sometimes waiting until the middle of the corner where it would upset the chassis’ balance. Not exactly a recipe for fast laps or a sense of driving joy.

Strike Two for the IS 350 was the omnipresent understeer, especially when pushed to the limit, a characteristic both Colum and I felt was likely being made worse by the F Sport package’s wider rear tires. Between the transmission’s unwillingness to downshift and the rear-biased tire setup, we simply couldn’t get the back end to come loose. In fact, attempts to use the throttle to induce oversteer instead resulted in even more understeer. A luxurious 4-door Scion FR-S this is not!

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 04

The Cadillac ATS wasn’t without its faults, either. Its 4-cylinder turbocharged engine was being asked to do an awful lot of heavy lifting when attached to a 3,500-lb AWD chassis, and it showed. After just a couple of hot laps, I could feel the Caddy’s engine starting to struggle down the straight-aways, as it became increasingly heat soaked. Not terribly surprising given the hot and sticky weather (reaching well above the 90-degree mark), but I wasn’t expecting the ATS to overheat so badly that it went into ‘safe’ mode, cutting power and limiting RPM on the third lap.

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 29After a few cool down laps I turned up the aggression again, and this time it was the Cadillac’s 6-speed automatic transmission that went into self-preservation mode, the dash lighting up and alarms going off, along with a digital message on the center display that stated, “immediate action required”. A bit of an ambiguous message for a racer like me, but I made the safe choice and opted to park the ATS in the shade, where its equally overworked Lexus counterpart soon joined it.

WHERE’S THE SPORT?

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 07

At this point, it’s fair to say both Colum and I were underwhelmed by the performance delivered by both of these alleged 3 Series fighters. The Lexus was quick in a straight line and had fade-free brakes with excellent pedal feel, but its power-on understeer was bewildering and its 8-speed automatic transmission also overheated shortly after the ATS’, giving us a similar “cool it” message.

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 26Despite my concerns that the AWD system would result in a lot of unwanted understeer, the ATS was the more willing of the two to change direction, plus it has superb steering feel and precision to go along with fade-free Brembo brakes. But its all-season tires were no match for the F Sport’s summer tires, and at no point did it feel like the AWD system was giving the Caddy a traction advantage coming out of the corners. Throw in a fun-sucking slushbox transmission and there was a notable absence of joy as we sat around in the paddock waiting for both cars to cool down.

In Cadillac’s defense, they do offer the 2.0-liter Turbo ATS with a 6-speed manual transmission, a gearbox that would unquestionably be better suited to the track. Sadly, GM didn’t have one available at the time, nor did they have a RWD version with the more potent 321 hp 3.6L V6 available, a trim level that’s strangely only available with an automatic transmission. Why Cadillac doesn’t offer enthusiast-buyers a RWD V6 model with a manual gearbox is beyond me, but perhaps we can look forward to an ATS-V that gives us exactly that.

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 11

Lexus, on the other hand, has no such defense, since the IS 350 F Sport is the top of the line model, so its shortcomings can’t be explained away by changes to its trim level. This is the best and fastest IS money can buy, unless Lexus decides to build a new IS-F, but then we’re getting into BMW M3 territory.

WHERE’S THE LAP TIMES?

track map

With the sun setting, both cars fully cooled off and ambient temps below 90-degrees, I was finally able to complete three flying laps in both cars without any safe mode intervention or other obvious signs of performance drop-off. Both cars were, of course, put in ‘Sport’ mode and had all stability and traction control systems turned off (or at least as off as they’d go).

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 09Despite the Cadillac being equipped with GM’s superb magnetic ride, featuring the same highly-tunable magnetorheological shock absorbers as the Corvette ZR1 and Camaro ZL1, it was the Lexus that felt better damped around the race track, having less body roll and a more poised feel as I ran it up onto the curbing at the apex of each corner. And when I decided to drive it less like a Scion FR-S, the IS 350 did start to feel more balanced and willing to turn-in and stay on line. The Lexus definitely requires more of a ‘slow in, fast out’ driving style, which for me takes some of the joy out of the experience, but it can still be an effective way to go fast, the F Sport posting a respectable lap time of 1-minute 26.6-seconds.

Compare Specs

2013 Cadillac ATS 2.0L Turbo
vs
2014 Lexus IS 350 F-Sport
Vehicle 2013 Cadillac ATS 2.0L Turbo Advantage 2014 Lexus IS 350 F-Sport
Engine 2.0L Turbo-4 - 3.5L V6
Horsepower 274 IS 350 306
Max. Torque 260 IS 350 277
Transmission 6-Speed Automatic IS 350 8-Speed Automatic
0-60 Time 5.8 seconds IS 350 5.6 seconds
Max Lateral g's 1.06g IS 350 1.07g
Max Braking g's 0.76g IS 350 0.93g
Max Speed 91.5 mph IS 350 99.5 mph
Total Lap Time 1:29.169 IS 350 1:26.610

Although it had more pitch and roll than expected, the Cadillac ATS was unquestionably the better balanced of the two vehicles, showing virtually no signs of turn-in understeer and a wonderful willingness to rotate by the apex. With more power on tap it would have been possible to induce even earlier rotation with the throttle, but even with the hard-working 4-cylinder turbo engine the ATS certainly lived up to the media hype while navigating the twist bits of our test track. If it’s not a better handling machine than the BMW 3 Series, it’s very, very close, and presumably the RWD version of the ATS is even pointier than our AWD test mule (Colum assures me it is).

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 17In the end the Caddy just didn’t have enough motor to keep up with the Lexus, though. With a best lap time of 1-minute 29.1-seconds, the ATS was getting left in the dust down the straight-aways. And because the IS 350 was on a high performance summer tire, the in-car data clearly shows its grip advantage, with big spikes in initial cornering g’s as well as a huge advantage in braking g’s to go along with a much steeper reduction of speed in the braking zones. Had the Caddy been equipped with comparable summer tires, the lap times would have been much closer.

THE VERDICT: CAN BMW REST EASY?

Lexus IS vs Cadillac ATS 03

Based on our results from this hot and sticky summer day, it’s impossible to proclaim either the Lexus or the Cadillac the new leader in the compact luxury sport sedan segment. Still, the ATS does indeed have Bimmer-hunting handling dynamics, and when you trim out its cleanly designed interior with red leather and carbon accents it’s downright sexy inside. Too bad Cadillac didn’t take more risks with its exterior styling, though, because its sheet metal still has a whiff of old man about it.

The IS 350, on the other hand, certainly has the extroverted styling (especially in F Sport trim) and onboard luxury and technology to rival BMW and anything else in its class, but despite posting the faster lap time the Lexus just doesn’t deliver the kind of driving excitement a rear-wheel drive sports sedan should.

For 50-grand, neither the ATS (at least in 2L Turbo Performance AWD trim) nor the IS 350 F Sport blend luxury, style and performance in a way the 3 Series does. But these are both first model year efforts, and with some joy-enhancing tweaks one of these contenders just might have what it takes to knock the 3 Series off its perch.

2014 Lexus IS 350 F Sport RWD

« Back
SWEEPSTAKES – OFFICIAL RULES, TERMS AND CONDITIONS

AutoGuide.com’s Monthly Overlay Newsletter Signup – By subscribing to our email newsletter, Entrants are eligible to win one (1) Amazon.com Gift Card (value of $100.00 USD). One (1) winner will be chosen every month at random and contacted by VerticalScope Inc.’s staff. *Amazon.com is not a sponsor of this promotion. Except as required by law, Amazon.com Gift Cards ("GCs") cannot be transferred for value or redeemed for cash. GCs may be used only for purchases of eligible goods at Amazon.com or certain of its affiliated websites. For complete terms and conditions, see www.amazon.com/gc-legal. GCs are issued by ACI Gift Cards, Inc., a Washington corporation. All Amazon ®, ™ & © are IP of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. No expiration date or service fees.

1. NO PURCHASE OR PAYMENT OF ANY KIND IS NECESSARY TO ENTER OR WIN THIS SWEEPSTAKES. AGE/RESIDENCY RESTRICTIONS, VOID WHERE PROHIBITED.

2. PRIZE: One (1) Winner will be randomly selected every month to each receive: one (1) $100.00 Amazon.com Gift Card (the “Prize Supplier”). Total approximate retail value of all prizes is approximately $100.00 USD. Prizes are not transferable and no cash or prize substitution is allowed. Prize package is awarded "as is" with no warranty or guarantee, either express or implied.

3. ELIGIBILITY: From the time of entry through the final date of prize fulfillment, each contest entrant and selected entrant must be a permanent lawful citizen and resident residing in the 50 United States or the District of Columbia or in Canada, and be twenty one (21) years of age or older. VOID IN PUERTO RICO, THE U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS, IN ALL FOREIGN COUNTRIES OUTSIDE OF THE UNITED STATES, AND ALL OTHER U.S. TERRITORIES OR CANADA AND POSSESSIONS AND WHERE PROHIBITED OR RESTRICTED BY LAW. Employees, officers, directors, agents and representatives, of the Sponsor and the Prize Supplier and each of their respective parent companies, affiliates, subsidiaries, advertising and promotion agencies, promotion partners and any entity involved in the development, production, implementation, administration or fulfillment of this Sweepstakes, and the immediate family members (e.g., spouse, mother, father, sister, brother, uncle, aunt, nephew, niece, grandparent, in-law, daughter and son, regardless of where they live) and persons living in the same household (whether or not related) of such individuals are not eligible to participate or win. Only one selected entrant per household. All decisions of the Sponsor with respect to this sweepstakes are final. The Sponsor shall have the right at any time to require proof of identity and failure to provide such proof may result in disqualification from the Sweepstakes.

4. ENTER BY INTERNET: You may enter this sweepstakes via the Internet by logging onto AutoGuide.com and subscribing to our email newsletter via the pop-up overlay.

5. SELECTION OF WINNER: One (1) Entrant will be selected by random selection who have subscribed to our email newsletter. The winner may be announced publicly on AutoGuide.com and will be contacted by VerticalScope Inc.’s staff. The winner will be required to provide a mailing address (that is not a P.O. box) to receive the prize which will be shipped free of charge.

6. ODDS OF WINNING: Odds of winning a prize are determined by the total number of eligible entries received.

7. RESTRICTIONS: The prize package consists of one (1) Amazon.com Gift Card with an approximate value of $100.00 USD. If prize cannot be awarded due to circumstances beyond the control of the Sponsor or Prize Supplier, no substitute prize will be awarded due to the unique nature of the prize. Sponsor and Prize Supplier shall not be liable to the winner or any person claiming through winner for failure to supply the prize or any part thereof, by reason of any acts of God, any action(s), regulation(s), order(s) or request(s) by any governmental or quasi-governmental entity (whether or not the action(s), regulations(s), order(s) or request(s) prove(s) to be invalid), equipment failure, utility failure, internet failure, terrorist acts, threatened terrorist acts, air raid, blackout, act of public enemy, earthquake, war (declared or undeclared), fire, flood, epidemic, explosion, unusually severe weather, hurricane, embargo, labor dispute or strike (whether legal or illegal) labor or material shortage, transportation interruption of any kind, work slow-down, civil disturbance, insurrection, riot, or any other cause beyond Sponsor's or Prize Supplier's control (collectively, "Force Majeure Event"). Sponsor shall not be responsible for any cancellations, delays, diversions or substitutions or any act or omissions whatsoever by the performers/events, other transportation companies or any other persons providing any of these services and accommodations to passengers including any results thereof such as changes in services or accommodations necessitated by same.

8. CONDITIONS: By entering the Sweepstakes, entrants agree to be bound by the Official Rules, Terms and Conditions and that Sponsor has the irrevocable right to use in perpetuity entrants' names, user names, likenesses, photographs, voices, home mailing address, biographical and prize information, and entry materials, without notice to entrants and without compensation or obligation, in any and all media now or hereafter known throughout the world, in any manner whatsoever, to advertise and promote Sponsor, its products and services, the Sweepstakes, and for any other purpose except where prohibited by law. Entrant waives the right to assert as a cost of winning a prize any and all costs of verification and redemption or travel to redeem said prize and any liability which might arise from redeeming or seeking to redeem said prize. Sponsor is not responsible for fraudulent calls or emails made to entrants not by the Sponsor. If the Sweepstakes is not capable of running as planned by reason of damage by computer viruses, worms or bugs, tampering, unauthorized intervention, fraud, technical limitations or failures, any Force Majeure Event or any other cause which, in the sole opinion of Sponsor, could corrupt, compromise, undermine or otherwise affect the administration, security, fairness, integrity, viability or proper conduct of the Sweepstakes, Sponsor reserves the right, in its sole and absolute discretion, to cancel, terminate, modify or suspend all or any part of the Sweepstakes, and to select a winner from among all eligible entries received by Sponsor up until the time of such cancellation, termination, modification or suspension, as applicable. Sponsor reserves the right in its sole discretion to disqualify any individual that (i) tampers or attempts to tamper with the entry process or the operations of this Sweepstakes in any manner, (ii) violates the Official Rules, Terms and Conditions or (iii) acts in an unsportsmanlike or disruptive manner, or with intent to annoy, abuse, threaten or harass any other person. CAUTION: ANY ATTEMPT BY AN ENTRANT OR ANY OTHER INDIVIDUAL TO DELIBERATELY DAMAGE OR UNDERMINE THE LEGITIMATE OPERATION OF THIS SWEEPSTAKES IS A VIOLATION OF CRIMINAL AND CIVIL LAWS. SHOULD SUCH AN ATTEMPT BE MADE, SPONSOR RESERVES THE RIGHT TO SEEK CIVIL AND/OR CRIMINAL PROSECUTION AND/OR DAMAGES FROM ANY SUCH PERSON TO THE FULLEST EXTENT PERMITTED BY LAW. Any expenses and receipt and use of the prize and federal, state and local taxes and fees applicable in connection with the prize awarded are the sole responsibility of the winner. An IRS Form 1099 will be issued in the name of the winner for the actual value of the prize received. This Sweepstakes is subject to all federal, state and local laws of the United States. VOID WHERE PROHIBITED. Sponsor, Prize Supplier, and their respective officers, directors, parent companies, affiliates, subsidiaries and advertising and promotion agencies, employees, representatives and agents are not responsible for and shall not be liable for (i) any injuries, losses or damages of any kind caused by a prize resulting from acceptance, possession or usage of the prize, or (ii) printing, distribution or production errors. Sponsor or its affiliates may rescind any promotion found to contain such errors without liability at its or their sole discretion.

9. SPONSOR: The Sponsor of this contest is VerticalScope Inc. (the owner and operator of AutoGuide.com), 111 Peter Street, Suite 700, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1.

Subscribe to our email newsletter and automatically be entered to win.
*Restrictions apply. See offer for details

Get Breaking Automotive News, Reviews and Video in your Facebook Feed!

Already Liked