Why You Should Buy Your Next Car at Costco

Craig Cole
by Craig Cole

Updated April 2019

Costco is more than just a membership warehouse. Sure, they sell pallets of blue jeans and ketchup by the gallon, but there are countless other products and services available.

They offer appliances and fine wine, can fill a prescription and even help you book a dream vacation. But did you know they’re also able to get you a killer price on a car? The Costco Auto Program is something many people have never heard of, even though it’s been around for 30 years. This can be an affordable and easy way to buy a new car, so let’s go into the details and see if it’s right for you.

No-Nonsense Process

“The value we’re bringing to members is both price and the process,” Rick Borg, executive vice president of the Costco Auto Program told AutoGuide. “We’ve kind of taken away the need to negotiate.”

Members will get the lowest price a dealer would ever be able to sell a car for, he says, all without any uncomfortable bargaining because Costco has already done the heavy lifting. Hate going into a dealer and putting up with aggressive sales tactics? This could be the car-buying route for you.

SEE ALSO: Five Dealer Options to Avoid and Five You Shouldn’t

Conservatively, Borg said the average savings for members is around $1,000. Of course, that figure would likely be higher if you’re purchasing a high-markup Lexus opposed to a Honda Fit, so you could drive away with more money in your pocket. Further sweetening things, this reduction is taken off the transaction price, not the MSRP, making the savings even more impressive.

Aside from monetary advantages, the company aims to keep every single one of its customers happy through a special outreach program. “This member advocacy group is there to support members at any stage of a transaction,” Borg said. Buyers can call whenever necessary to get questions answered or to address any potential concerns, like verifying a vehicle price or checking on the availability of replacement parts.

Beyond factory-fresh automobiles, the program also covers used models, though not just any second-hand clunker is eligible. “It’s for new cars and certified pre-owned and select pre owned [vehicles],” said Gina Paolino, president of the Costco Auto Program. These cars and trucks need to have at least 12 months and 12,000 miles remaining on their comprehensive manufacturer warranties to be eligible. In addition to new and used vehicles, members can also purchase RVs, motorcycles and various powersports products through the program.

Buying in Bulk, Saving in Spades

How is Costco able to offer such competitive pricing? Well, ingeniously, they’ve applied the same business model to selling automobiles that they’ve used to great effect wholesaling snack food, mattresses and office equipment. The secret is volume. By moving a lot of metal, they can get prices as low as possible. Costco doesn’t, however, actually sell vehicles themselves — it partners with specially certified dealerships.

Curiously, not just any dealer can sell to Costco members. “We only select certain dealerships in a market area,” the best of the best, Paolino said. So, if you’re looking for a new Accord, there may only be one Honda showroom in your town that’s partnered with Costco.

These dealerships “agree to give Costco… very aggressive pricing on the purchases of those vehicles,” Borg said, and in turn, they get higher sales volumes and happier buyers. It’s a win-win for everyone, except perhaps Costco. They didn’t get involved in car sales to make money; instead, it’s just another service they offer to keep customers happy.

Proving the Costco Auto Program makes the car-buying process better, more than 96 percent of members that responded to the company’s after-sale survey in 2018 gave the overall experience a high score. Value and service were similarly praised.

On the dealer side of this equation, “They want to get conquest sales,” noted Paolino, adding that volume is a huge measure of success for dealers. “Because of the exclusivity, we have dealers that are on waiting lists,” said Borg. So clearly, the program is beneficial to more than just Costco members.

To guarantee such terrific deals, Costco’s staff is constantly doing market research, calculating supply levels, verifying available incentives, and checking on factory rebates to come up with the lowest prices possible. “We do an extensive amount of background work… moving toward the pricing dealers can offer members,” said Borg. Adding an extra layer of complexity, these discounts vary from region to region and season to season.

SEE ALSO: Top 10 Most Dependable Automakers of 2019: J.D. Power

Once Costco determines a price, “Dealers decide if it’s something they want to offer,” said Paolino. Accordingly, not every make or model will be available in all areas, though Borg said, “Pretty much, it’s across the board in most markets.” Vehicles from a wide swath of mass-market brands are on the menu, ranging from Chevrolet and Kia, to BMW. “Most markets will have most brands represented,” he added, though, “We don’t have any Ferrari or Lamborghini dealers on the program … Not yet.”

Customer-First Attitude

Everyone appreciates a good deal, but aggressive pricing is far from Costco’s only focus. According to Borg, they make extraordinary efforts to educate participating dealers so they keep their members pleased. Accordingly, not every salesperson can work with Costco customers; only ones that have proper schooling, high customer service scores and many years of experience qualify. “We go to great pains to train those people and certify those people every year,” Borg said.

SEE ALSO: Top 10 Least Dependable Automakers 2019: J.D. Power

Of course, participating dealers must have top-notch ratings and be geographically reasonable for members. Someone living in Las Vegas shouldn’t have to drive all the way to Sacramento just to buy a vehicle and fortunately, they don’t have to, because there are more than 3,000 participating Costco franchises in the country.

This buyer-focused attitude is a boon for both members and participating dealerships. Chris Pappas, general manager, Toyota of Lake City in Seattle, Washington, said, “When the customers come in, they know they have a pre-negotiated price … And they feel good about it.”

Ensuring the entire experience is as pleasant as possible, Pappas noted, “There’s a safety net there too, to ensure the consumer gets the value they’re supposed to get.” Costco is “super aggressive” on pricing and audits transactions to make sure dealers play fairly.

Surprisingly, sales through the Costco Auto Program aren’t necessarily big money makers for dealers. “It’s not profitable [up front],” Pappas said. “You kind of have to look past the initial transaction.” However, he said money can be made down the road with trade-ins and vehicle service, because happy customers are often return customers.

Pappas said another benefit to participating dealers is that “there’s a very high closing percent.” Around eight of 10 Costco members who go to his showroom with an appointment end up with a new vehicle. Typical transaction rates are much lower. He said, “[The] normal closing percent would be around 10 percent.” To keep up, seven members of Pappas’ 30-person sales team are certified to work with Costco members.

SEE ALSO: Do I Really Need Premium Gas?

But what about franchise laws? Is Costco running afoul of these sometimes draconian regulations? “We obviously don’t sell cars ourselves … [they] can only be sold [through] franchised dealers,” Borg said, meaning all of their activities are on the up and up. Further clarifying things, Paolino noted, “We don’t get a per-sale or per-transaction fee,” though dealers do pay a small amount for marketing.

Continued Growth

It seems not many of the roughly 50 million Costco members in the U.S. are familiar with the company’s automotive business, but nevertheless, it’s still a popular program, as evinced by growing sales. In fact, it set several records in 2018. Members purchased more than 650,000 vehicles, a 25 percent year-over-year jump, plus the limited-time General Motors Holiday Sales Event saw deliveries increase by 22 percent compared to the prior year.

Of the 650,000 cars and trucks sold in 2018, 82 percent were new. Certified pre-owned vehicles made up about 16 percent of that total.

Mirroring recent automotive trends, SUVs accounted for around 48 percent of sales, trucks about 8 percent. Things were a little different for the recent Holiday Sales Event, with 47 percent of vehicles sold being utility models and 37 percent pickups.

SEE ALSO: Top 10 Best Used Car Bargains: 2019

To keep pace with this growing demand, in 2019 the Costco Auto Program will continue to expand, both by offering more sales promotions and increasing the number of people on its team, which is currently at about 300.

You can learn more about the Costco Auto Program and its various services through its website at this link. The program also allows Costco members to shop for handicap accessible vans and SUVs and power sport vehicles like side by sides as well, so if you want to get a deal on either of those speciality products, this may be the best way to go about doing it.

If you have further questions about the Costco Auto Program, you can also contact the company’s auto sales department directly at 1-800-348-2582. The call center is open from 6 a.m. to 7p.m. PT from Monday to Friday and from 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. PT on Saturdays and Sundays.

Craig Cole
Craig Cole

Born and raised in metro Detroit, Craig was steeped in mechanics from childhood. He feels as much at home with a wrench or welding gun in his hand as he does behind the wheel or in front of a camera. Putting his Bachelor's Degree in Journalism to good use, he's always pumping out videos, reviews, and features for AutoGuide.com. When the workday is over, he can be found out driving his fully restored 1936 Ford V8 sedan. Craig has covered the automotive industry full time for more than 10 years and is a member of the Automotive Press Association (APA) and Midwest Automotive Media Association (MAMA).

More by Craig Cole

Join the conversation
2 of 13 comments
  • Pat Pat on Jun 09, 2016

    They do this at car dealerships?

  • Ck Ck on Sep 10, 2016

    Please read this before you buy a car through this scam of a program. Costco will refer you to a dealership for a specific vehicle. However, once you arrive on the lot, that dealership can sell you any vehicle they choose under the guise of the Costco program. No warranties, no standards, no pre-inspection. They will tack on extras and haggle on price, as happened to me. I am out $23,000 as a result. Costco has done absolutely nothing to assist me - in fact, the rep I spoke with implied it was my fault for being led to believe I was buying through the Costco program when I really was not. I have written documentation from the dealer stating that I was buying through the Costco program while also trying to upsell me on extrassupposedly something Costco protects you from. I'm now going to have to spend additional money to hire an attorney to work with me. I cannot believe the nightmare this has become, or how terribly Costco has handled the whole thing. Don't trust Costco.