Is a Carefree Auto Membership Worth It?

To learn more about our editorial integrity policy and how we make money through affiliate partnerships, read our full disclosure here.

Carefree Auto offers drivers roadside assistance, discounts on routine maintenance, and auto repair reimbursements. But are the benefits worth the cost of membership?

In this review, we take a closer look at Carefree Auto membership perks, breaking down the company’s costs, coverage, and reputation. We’ll help you decide whether Carefree Auto is a good choice to help lower the costs associated with maintenance and mechanical breakdowns.

If you’re looking for more vehicle protection than is offered by Carefree Auto, we will also recommend a couple of the best extended car warranty companies in the industry.

Carefree Auto provides roadside assistance and discounts on a variety of mechanical breakdown services for a low monthly cost. However, the membership program does not cover repairs as comprehensively as typical third-party extended warranty providers.

While Carefree Auto can reimburse you a fraction of the cost of select mechanical repairs, extended car warranties cover the entire repair—but this type of coverage is much more expensive. If you’re thinking you may benefit from better breakdown coverage, you can read more about our top recommendations for reputable extended car warranty companies below.

Carefree Auto is not a standard extended car warranty provider. Instead of offering vehicle service contracts, Carefree Auto is a membership-based program that provides benefits to help you save money in the event of a mechanical breakdown.

Carefree Auto, whose office is located on El Cajon Blvd in San Diego, CA, is owned by Coverdell and Company, which provides consumer discount programs to more than six million people across the country. These companies have been working together for over 50 years, helping customers save money on routine auto maintenance and unexpected repair costs.

Carefree Auto is upfront about the cost of membership on its website. Coverage costs $24.95 per month regardless of how many vehicles you own. If you have questions about price or wish to speak with a representative about this offer, call 888-801-2584.

To cash in on your membership perks, simply call the number on your Carefree Auto membership card to submit a repair reimbursement claim or get roadside assistance. To get your maintenance discounts, you’ll need to download a coupon specific to the repair facility you choose, which you can do from the Carefree Auto website.

Carefree Auto has an A+ rating on the Better Business Bureau (BBB), which bodes well for the company’s reliability. There is only one customer review on the BBB for Carefree Auto, in which the customer said they were able to find coupons on retailers’ websites that offered a better discount than Carefree Auto.

Because there are so few reviews online about Carefree Auto, it’s hard to judge its industry reputation and quality of customer care. Its parent company, Coverdell and Company, has similarly low numbers of reviews on the BBB, most of which detail difficulty canceling memberships or making recurring payments for services customers claimed to never have signed up for.

Use the buttons below to get a free quote for an Endurance coverage plan tailored to your vehicle, and learn more about the provider in our complete Endurance warranty review.