Navigating the 10 Worst U.S. Cities for Drivers Staff
by Staff
Photo credit: Kichigin /

Driving in some U.S. cities can be more challenging than others, as indicated by a recent study conducted by Forbes Advisor. The study assessed various aspects of driving across 47 metropolitan areas in the United States. The findings reveal that cities like Oakland, California, and Miami, Florida, rank among the most difficult places for drivers.

Criteria for Ranking

The cities were evaluated based on 15 different metrics, categorized into four main areas: driving experience, driver safety, cost of car ownership, and accessibility to car maintenance. These metrics include factors such as gas prices, insurance rates, average commute times, and weather conditions affecting driving.

Top Ten Cities with Driving Challenges

The cities that topped the list as the most challenging for drivers are:

  • Oakland, CA
  • Miami, FL
  • San Francisco, CA
  • Houston, TX
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • New York City, NY
  • Chicago, IL
  • Atlanta, GA
  • Dallas, TX
  • Portland, OR

Driving Costs and Challenges in Specific Cities

The analysis identified several cities where drivers face unique challenges. Oakland is highlighted as the city with the most comprehensive challenges. In terms of specific experiences, Boston is at the forefront with the least favorable driving conditions. Albuquerque raises concerns due to its safety issues, making it the most hazardous for drivers. The financial burden of driving is highest in New York City, primarily due to steep insurance rates. Moreover, Memphis stands out for having the most limited access to car maintenance facilities.

Gas Prices and Insurance Costs Impact

The cost of driving is heavily influenced by local factors, such as gas prices and insurance premiums. In California, particularly in Los Angeles and Long Beach, drivers are subject to gas prices that far exceed the national average. These high costs are further exacerbated by the insurance rates in urban areas, where dense traffic and frequent accidents lead to increased insurance expenses for residents.

The Role of Traffic and Weather

Traffic congestion and adverse weather conditions also play a critical role in the driving experience. The worst-ranked cities in the study experience severe traffic jams, which are coupled with low average speeds during peak traffic hours. Additionally, these cities tend to have a higher incidence of weather-related disruptions, compounding the challenges for daily commuters.

For more details on the rankings and methodology used in the study, as well as an interactive map and a comprehensive list of the cities, the full report is available for further exploration.

Become an AutoGuide insider. Get the latest from the automotive world first by subscribing to our newsletter here.

This article was co-written using AI and was then heavily edited and optimized by our editorial team. Staff Staff

More by Staff

Join the conversation