Autopom! and CarShield are two of the best extended auto warranty companies on the market, offering high-end coverage at lower rates than many others in the industry. By comparing autopom! vs. CarShield head to head, you can get a better sense of which company may be right for you.

While autopom! may have lower-cost options for long-term coverage, CarShield offers flexible terms and lower monthly payments for certain plans. Read on to learn more about each of these providers, and start comparing how much each company’s plans would cost for your vehicle by clicking below.

CarShield vs. autopom! Extended Warranties
AutoGuide reviewed the top car warranty companies to find the best.
Compare CarShield and autopom! by getting a customized quote from each.
Best Value Best Customer Experience
CarShield autopom!
★★★★½ ★★★★½
Get Quote Get Quote
(800) 563-2761 (888) 691-2354

To learn more about our editorial integrity policy and how we make money through affiliate partnerships, read our full disclosure here.

Autopom! vs. CarShield Highlights

autopom! CarShield
Reputation 4.7 4.1
Coverage 4.4 5.0
Price 4.4 5.0
Transparency 4.0 4.3
Customer Service 4.6 4.4
Overall Rating 4.4 4.6

Autopom!: Best Customer Service

Autopom! offers what may be the best customer service in the industry. The company receives top marks from customers both on the Better Business Bureau (BBB) website (4.3 out of 5.0 stars) and Trustpilot (4.8 out of 5.0 stars). While it has only been around for 10 years, the company has established a reputation as a trusted provider that offers top-tier coverage. Autopom! contracts are available in all 50 states.

CarShield: Best Value

CarShield contracts are available in every state except California. It is a bit older than autopom! with 16 years of experience in the industry. CarShield offers its customers low rates and high-level coverage. It’s also one of the only top-tier providers to offer specialty coverage for motorcycles and all-terrain vehicles.

Autopom! vs. CarShield: Coverage

Autopom! contracts can cover your vehicle for up to 7 years or 150,000 miles, whichever comes first. CarShield offers slightly higher coverage terms that can go up to 200,000 miles.

Autopom! Extended Warranty Plans

  • Exclusionary: Bumper-to-bumper warranty that covers virtually all mechanical and electrical components
  • High-Level: Covers an extensive list of named components such as the engine, transmission, drive axle, steering, suspension, braking, air conditioning, cooling, fuel, and electrical systems
  • Mid-Level: Protects major systems such as the engine, transmission, drive axle, steering, braking, air conditioning, and electrical
  • Powertrain Plus: Provides basic protection for the engine, transmission, drive axle, and air conditioning

CarShield Extended Warranty Plans

  • Diamond: An exclusionary bumper-to-bumper coverage contract
  • Platinum: Comprehensive coverage for high-mileage vehicles that includes most mechanical and electrical parts
  • Gold: An expanded powertrain plan that covers everything in the lower-tier Silver plan, plus the alternator, starter, air conditioning, and power windows
  • Silver: Powertrain warranty that covers all lubricated engine parts, as well as the transmission, drive axle, and water pump
  • Aluminum: Specialty coverage for many electrical and computer-related parts, such as the engine control module, starter, alternator, and GPS
  • Motorcycle & ATV:  Provides protection for motorcycles and ATVs

Top-level coverage from both providers is largely similar. However, CarShield offers more coverage options, as well as protection for motorcycles and ATVs, which autopom! does not have.

Comparing Benefits and Add-Ons

Autopom! and CarShield offer similar additional benefits, but they come with different reimbursement amounts. A full comparison is detailed in the chart below.

Benefit autopom! CarShield
24/7 Roadside Assistance
Flat Tire Services
Battery Jump-Starts
Towing $100 reimbursement $75 reimbursement
Lockout Services
Trip Interruption Coverage Up to $150 per day for 3 days Up to $50 per day for 3 days
Rental Car Reimbursement Up to $35 per day for 5 days Up to $40 per day for 4 days

Autopom! offers a higher reimbursement for towing and trip interruption expenses, as well as a longer rental car coverage period. However, CarShield offers a higher daily dollar limit for rental reimbursement. These services can come in handy if you experience a mechanical breakdown that leaves your vehicle inoperable or if you need to leave your car at the repair shop for multiple days.

Autopom! vs. CarShield: Costs

We reached out for quotes from both autopom! and CarShield for bumper-to-bumper and powertrain vehicle protection plans. Details of these offers are outlined in the charts below. Keep in mind that these are quotes for one particular vehicle, and your own quotes will differ depending on factors such as:

  • The type of vehicle you drive
  • Your vehicle’s age and mileage
  • The deductible you choose
  • Your location

Bumper-to-Bumper Warranty Cost

The following quotes were given for a 2017 Ford Explorer with 45,000 miles on it in Raleigh, North Carolina.

 
Coverage Term Monthly Payment Total Cost Down Payment Deductible
autopom! 5 years/
100,000 miles
$136.04 per month for 24 months $3,264.96 First month’s payment $100.00
CarShield Unlimited $129.99 per month N/A First month’s payment $100.00

Powertrain Warranty Cost

The following quotes were given for a 2012 Honda Civic with 88,000 miles on it in Raleigh, North Carolina.

Coverage Term Monthly Payment Total Cost Down Payment Deductible
autopom! 4 years/
48,000 miles
$102.92 per month for 24 months $2,470.08 First month’s payment $100.00
CarShield Unlimited $129.99 per month N/A First month’s payment $100.00

Autopom! offered a lower monthly quote for powertrain coverage but a higher monthly payment for bumper-to-bumper protection. However, drivers only make 24 monthly payments for five years of autopom! bumper-to-bumper coverage, totaling $3,264.96. At the rate quoted above, the CarShield contract would cost $7,799.40 after five years of month-to-month payments, which is significantly more expensive.

When we reached out for quotes, our researchers were only offered unlimited coverage plans from CarShield. However, the provider also offers plan options with specified term limits, which may be a more cost-effective choice in the long run.

Autopom! vs. CarShield: Customer Service

Autopom! has a significantly better customer service record than CarShield. CarShield is not accredited by the BBB and has a very low BBB score. While CarShield has a respectable 4.1 out of 5.0-star Trustpilot rating, autopom! scores even better. See below for a detailed comparison between the two providers’ customer service ratings.

BBB Accreditation BBB Rating BBB Customer Rating Trustpilot Score
autopom! Yes A+ 4.3 stars 4.8 stars
CarShield No F 1.4 stars 4.1 stars

It’s worth noting that we’ve chosen CarShield as one of our top recommended providers despite its low BBB score. Companies have to pay a fee for BBB accreditation that can cost thousands of dollars, so some providers opt to skip getting this distinction.

Final Thoughts on These Top Providers

While autopom! offers lower rates and boasts better customer service scores, CarShield has better coverage options and much longer coverage terms for its vehicle service contracts. If you are purchasing protection for a newer vehicle, you are likely to find a better rate with autopom!, but older vehicles may not be eligible for autopom! coverage.

CarShield contracts may be cheaper in the short term and offer greater flexibility, as customers have the option to pay by the month rather than commit to a long-term contract.

Overall, we think both providers can offer peace of mind on the road. You can learn more about these companies in our CarShield review and autopom! review, and start comparing costs for yourself by using the buttons below to get free quotes.

CarShield vs. autopom! Extended Warranties
AutoGuide reviewed the top car warranty companies to find the best.
Compare CarShield and autopom! by getting a customized quote from each.
Best Value Best Customer Experience
CarShield autopom!
★★★★½ ★★★★½
Get Quote Get Quote
(800) 563-2761 (888) 691-2354